Interactive Projector vs Smartboard: Which One Is the Best?

Interactive Projector vs Smartboard: Which One Is the Best?
Spread the love

When setting up a projection room for your office or school, you might find it hard to decide what is better: an interactive projector or smartboard. These two have the same function, and both would serve you equally well. However, there are some differences which you need to be aware of.

An interactive projector has two main elements. The first one is a whiteboard that is used as a screen and the second one is a projector which has a lens to project images.

You should mount the projector somewhere in the room, and make adjustments until the projection fits the whiteboard. Infrared or DLP technology makes these projectors interacting by recognizing your movements.

On the other hand, smartboards are high-tech screens which display pictures or videos while allowing free touchscreen interaction. A remote or a pen controls them, and the way they are designed is similar to the way tablets are used only they are larger.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector vs. Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board: Direct Comparison

Product 1: Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

-Spec/Feature/Value #1: Weight: 1.1 pounds

-Spec/Feature/Value #2: Picture quality: Diminishes over time

-Spec/Feature/Value #3: Maintenance Cost: High, lamps need to be replaced often

-Spec/Feature/Value #4: Display Type: LED

-Spec/Feature/Value #5: Multi-touch support: No

-Spec/Feature/Value #6: Background Noise: Significant

Product 2: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

-Spec/Feature/Value #1: Weight: 115 pounds

-Spec/Feature/Value #2: Picture Quality: Stays the same for years

-Spec/Feature/Value #3: Maintenance Cost: No cost at all

-Spec/Feature/Value #4: Display Type: LCD

-Spec/Feature/Value #5: Multi-touch support: Yes

-Spec/Feature/Value #6: Background Noise: none

Breaking It Down

We will closely look at the six main points of differences of an interactive projector vs smartboard to find out which is best suited for your office or classroom setting.

1. Weight

The weight of the product is important since it usually equates to the item’s portability and durability. This will solely depend on your preference.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

Weighing only 1.1 pounds, this product is excellent for anyone who tends to move a lot and hold projections in different rooms. The dimensions are also small, so you can fit this projector in your work bag for easy transportation.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

This one is a bit on the heavy side, featuring the weight of 115 pounds, so it’s not the best choice for those who have to transfer from one projection hall to another often. However, this won’t be a problem if you’re planning to use the screen in the same room every time.

Winner: Tie

2. Picture Quality

Picture quality is the most important feature of both projectors and smartboards since it ensures that your audience can clearly see what want to display on the screen.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

Portable projectors are less expensive than smartboards, but they are known to lose picture quality over time. This is not good as dull images can strain the eyes of those watching the projection.

Also, you might be required to drop the curtains and turn off any room lights to guarantee that the projection can be seen as clearly as possible. This becomes an even bigger problem if your LED lamp is due for a change, as the image starts to lose quality.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Smartboards have higher quality displays compared to the portable projectors. The picture quality stays the same no matter how often you use this product. Furthermore, you can adjust the brightness to suit your preferences.

Winner: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

3. Maintenance Cost

Almost all products require maintenance to ensure their longevity, so the cost of maintenance is something that you need to consider to ensure that you wouldn’t be spending a lot regularly.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

Interactive projectors have lamps that need to be taken care of quite often. This process can become bothersome and expensive after some time. If you don’t replace your projector lamp when it’s due, the quality of the picture will significantly drop.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Smartboards are more expensive than projectors, but you will have no additional expenses in the near future.

Winner: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

4. Display Type

The display type is important for your audience’s comfort and convenience.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

This projector features a LED lamp that is used for displaying the picture. LED lights are usually inferior to LCD, but the quality of this product is high, so you shouldn’t encounter any problems.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Its LCD touchscreen with a digital signature display is quite good and will last for a long time before showing any signs of deterioration.

Winner: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

5. Multi-Touch Support

This is a very significant feature for classrooms and office meetings since students can work on the same project without any complications and colleagues at work can synchronize their ideas during meetings.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

This product doesn’t have multi-touch support, and generally none of the available interactive projectors have this feature. Even the most expensive ones don’t have it as the technology isn’t there yet.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

This smartboard supports up to four different pairs of hands at the same time.

Winner: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

6. Background Noise

Noise coming from the machine or equipment is a consideration since it can affect the audience’s focus or concentration.

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

A projector can have a disadvantage in a classroom because of students reporting being sensitive to and getting distracted by the background noise. This background noise is due the projector fans spinning continually to get rid of heat build up.

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Interactive smartboards feature almost no background noise. This is another reason why teachers all around the world prefer them.

Winner: Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Final Recount

  • HC40 Full 3D 4K Interactive Portable Projector and Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board tie at one section.
  • HC40 Full 3D 4K Interactive Portable Projector won 1 out of 1 out of 5 sections.
  • Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board won 5 out of 5 sections.

Pros and Cons

Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • Portable
  • Compact
  • High quality
  • Two-year warranty
  • 5x zoom option
  • 4K decoding for the highest picture quality

Cons:

  • LED lamp
  • No multi-touch support
  • High maintenance cost
  • Distracting background noise

Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board

Pros:

  • High-quality LCD
  • Multiple resolution options
  • Optical display
  • No additional cost after making the purchase
  • Built-in speaker
  • WiFi and 3G internet included
  • Multi-Touch feature

Cons:

  • Very heavy and hard to transport
  • Expensive

Final Verdict

If you couldn’t decide whether to choose an interactive projector vs smartboard, you now have all the answers.

The Astar AWB-6507 Electronic Interactive Smart Writing Board is a clear winner in almost all of the sections. It provides better durability and picture quality at a higher price. If you choose this smartboard, you won’t ever have to worry about students or colleagues complaining about display straining their eyes. The multi-touch feature is another bonus that is a must in friendly work environments.

However, if you move often and need to hold projections in different avenues, you should opt for the Nierbo HC40 Interactive Portable Projector because of its small dimensions and weight.

Click here to add a comment

Leave a comment: